Choosing between a metal roof vs shingle roof in Florida? Both can be great — it comes down to budget, how long you’ll stay in the home, and your insurance strategy. Here’s the honest breakdown we give our own customers.
Cost
Architectural shingles are the budget-friendly option upfront. Metal typically costs roughly 2–3× more to install — but lasts two to three times longer, so lifetime cost often favors metal.
Lifespan in Florida heat
Florida sun is brutal on asphalt: expect 15–20 years from shingles here (less than in cooler states). A properly installed metal roof commonly lasts 40–50 years.
Hurricane and wind performance
Modern shingles are rated to 130 mph when installed correctly; standing-seam metal systems routinely carry the highest wind ratings and shed debris better. Many insurers offer meaningful premium discounts for metal roofs.
Energy efficiency
Metal reflects solar heat and can cut cooling costs 10–25%. Shingles absorb heat, though lighter “cool roof” colors help.
The bottom line
Staying 10+ years or want the strongest storm performance? Metal usually wins. Need the lowest upfront cost or plan to sell soon? Quality architectural shingles are the smart play. We install both — and we’ll give you a straight recommendation for your specific house.
Free Estimate Within 24 Hours
3 Squares Roofing is a licensed and insured Florida roofing contractor serving Miami-Dade and Broward. Tell us what is going on with your roof and we will get you a free, no-pressure estimate within 24 hours.
Keep reading.
Get your free written estimate.
A detailed inspection and a line-item price within 24 hours — no pressure, no obligation.